Springfield, IL


Extra Fresh, Extra Fast

Fast, Fresh, Local

Our Delicious Story

Toasty-Subs is a locally owned sandwich shop in Springfield, IL offering fresh & Homemade style sandwiches that are fast & affordable. Our bread is made fresh from scratch everyday at the store.

Featured Delicacies

Fresh off the press!

All of our sandwiches and wraps are served a regular side. You can upgrade to a primum side from selected options for just $2.99

Itallian Stallion


Spicy Italian style sandwich on Italian herb and cheese bread, panini pressed with ham, salami, pepperoni, topped with mayo, tomatoes, onion, banana peppers, Jalapeño, and Pepper Jack cheese.

Pressed Chicken Bacon Ranch


Grilled chicken strips with Applewood Smoked Bacon, Creamy Provolone & shredded Mozzarella, and Ranch dressing on French, served pressed.

Buffalo Cauliflower


Hand-breaded baked cauliflower on French bread with lettuce, onion, tomatoes, and Pepper Jack cheese with our homemade dressing

The Toasty Club


Toasty-Subs Special Club with ham, turkey, bacon, and cheddar cheese, served toasted on sweet bread.

Classic Cubano


Pressed pulled pork, ham, & provolone cheeses with yellow mustard and dill pickle on French bread, served pressed



Traditional Bombay street sandwich pressed on Texas Toast with mint chutney, potatoes, red onions, tomatoes with shredded mozzarella 

Make your next occasion at Toasty